Since 2020, our articles have offered you guidance on enhancing your search for, organizing, and using information. Research, information monitoring, sources, tools, and generative artificial intelligence. To reflect the diverse needs of our readers, we have created a journey metaphor, culinary reference, and gardening analogy to illustrate this path. Just like a travel guide, this summary provides a map, taking you from your initial query to your final decision.
Before you begin: Identify your needs.
A successful journey starts with a clear destination. When it comes to information, it’s no different. First, choose the right tool. Literature research answers a specific question by reviewing what has been published. In contrast, information monitoring is an ongoing process that tracks the evolution of a specific topic by constantly monitoring relevant resources.
Next, clarify your need with your information specialist accurately understands your requirements, provide the following details:
- A concise statement outlining your objective and the particular need you are trying to satisfy.
- Any previously discovered resources, such as relevant articles or publications, that may be relevant.
- The temporal, geographic and linguistic limits of your search.
- The specialized terminology associated with your topic.
- Any unique constraints specific to your situation.
This is the whole purpose of the initial consultation. After 20 years of information related projects, confirms that clearly defining needs is essential.
In a monitoring project, pay close attention to the start. The process (in French only) must be tailored to your organization’s unique culture. Secure your manager’s support and align the project with the strategic plan. Keep a log of your decisions and establish a feedback mechanism, as user needs will evolve. To reduce potential pitfalls, consider starting with a small pilot project.
Selecting Sources: Prioritize Quality Over Quantity
In the culinary arts, the highest quality recipe cannot mask inferior ingredients. The same is true for information: no single source is comprehensive. Access to free resources like PubMed and Google Scholar provides an initial entry point. Paid databases, such as Medline, Embase, or CINAHL, offer advanced features like thesauri and search syntax, enabling you to further refine your search. To maximize the benefits of literature monitoring, it is essential to leverage both free and paid resources.
Additionally, explore the realm of gray literature, including government reports, dissertations, and conference proceedings. Sometimes published more quickly, it can provide access to neutral or negative results—which are valuable but rarely found in white literature. However, its quality varies, and identifying it takes time.
When evaluating information, consider these factors: relevance, target audience, authority, reliability, validity, accuracy, and timeliness. Be wary of predatory journals. Here are some warning signs:
- Charging submission fees;
- Promising rapid publication;
- Neglecting the website or questionable metrics.
Then check the journal in the DOAJ or the COPE member list, and cross-reference your sources. Finally, your sources change over time. A dashboard that compiles them helps you keep your monitoring up to date.
Equipping Your Collection: Gathering Without Burning Out
A gardener selects their tools based on the harvest they’re aiming for. In literature searches, Boolean operators are your primary tools:
- AND limits results to documents that address both concepts;
- OR broadens the scope by accepting either one;
- NOT excludes a concept;
- Quotation marks, truncation (*), and parentheses refine the strategy.
To monitor information, RSS feeds bring the information to you, so you don’t have to visit each site individually. You can also avoid social media algorithms. If a page doesn’t offer a feed, you can create one with tools like FetchRSS or RSS.app.
An aggregator such as Feedly or Inoreader brings all your feeds together in one place. Consider factors like user experience, the range of covered sources, pricing, and export options when selecting one. The retirement of Netvibes in June 2025 should remind you to always have a backup plan.
For tool comparisons, refer to the Répertoire d’outils numériques de veille de la Communauté de pratique de veille en santé et services sociaux du Québec (CdPVeille3S). Since 2009, this community of practice has brought together many information professionals from the health and social services network. Their best practices are available for free on the Passerelles platform.
Keep Human Judgment in Control
Keeping tabs on everything can lead to information overload or infobesity, and the fear of missing out (FOMO) often motivates people to do just that. However, it’s important to remember that monitoring isn’t about being exhaustive. It’s about selecting only the most relevant, trustworthy, and carefully curated information.
Generative artificial intelligence (GAI) can be a helpful tool, but it has the potential to produce “hallucinations,” and its default settings may not be adequate. To fully benefit from it, incorporate information science principles into your prompts:
- Establish a context, just as you would in a reference interview;
- Choose precise vocabulary;
- Structure your query into facets: subject, audience, format, location, time period;Iterate and refine, as you would with a research equation;
- Request sources and specify the output format.
Human judgment also involves ethics. Entrusting a research project or monitoring task means sharing sensitive information. Choose a partner who protects the confidentiality of your projects and upholds copyright laws. Their findings should be presented in an unbiased and impartial manner.
It’s crucial to dispel the myth that intelligence gathering is exclusive to large entities and equates to espionage. It relies on open-source or gray-source information, never on black-source information.
The techniques might evolve, but the approach remains the same: identify the need, choose your sources, establish a system for gathering information, and exercise critical thinking. Céline Bélanger encourages aspiring entrepreneurs to maintain a group of five reliable contacts. Similarly, when it comes to information gathering, it’s wiser to avoid working alone. At Cogniges, we are dedicated to your success, offering training and managing your research or intelligence-gathering project from start to finish.
To learn more
The hyperlinks in this text lead to specific articles that have been published since 2020. To access the comprehensive versions of all articles, please visit the Cogniges website.